Select Page

Award-Winning Pies

Flat lay view of Blueberry Pie

The Best Pies in Bradenton

MERMAID PIES & SANDWICHES

Savor the spirit of the sea and award-winning pies — made fresh daily — at Mermaid Pies & Sandwiches near Anna Maria Island in Bradenton, Florida. Serving up sweets, sandwiches and seafood to share, this laid-back lunch spot is inspired by the Florida lifestyle and the legacy of long-time local restaurateur Andrea Spring. A celebrated competitor in the American Pie Council’s National Pie Championships, Andrea’s award-winning pie recipes, from Key Lime to Peanut Butter Truffle, are among the Mermaid’s most-ordered and best-loved still today.

Whether your looking for a tasty lunch to take to the beach or a fresh-made pie to celebrate a holiday or special occasion, the Mermaid is here to provide the tastiest flavors and most memorable service you will find in the Bradenton/Sarasota area.

 

Pies & Sandwiches

The Mermaid’s Menu

All Items
  • All Items
  • Cookies
  • Pies
  • Quiche
  • Sandwiches
  • Seafood
  • Sides
  • Soups

Coconut Cream Pie

$5.95 slice / $23.95 whole

Chocolate Cream Pie

$5.95 slice / $23.95 whole

Peach Pie

$5.95 slice / $22.95 whole

Strawberry Pie

$5.95 slice / $24.95 whole

Mixed Berry Pie

$5.95 slice / $25.95 whole

Lemon Meringue Pie

$5.95 slice / $24.95 whole

Tomato Pie

$5.95 slice / $22.95 whole

Key West Crunch Pie

$5.95 slice / $38.95 whole

Chocolate Raisin Walnut Pie

$5.95 slice / $38.95 whole

Key Lime

$2 single / $9 half / $18 dozen

Peanut Butter Truffle Pie

$5.95 slice / $28.95 whole

Pecan Pie

$5.95 slice / $24.95 whole

Key Lime Pie

$5.95 slice / $22.95 whole

Blueberry Pie

$5.95 slice / $25.95 whole

Cherry Pie

$5.95 slice / $24.95 whole

Prince Edward Island Mussels

  • 10-pound minimum

Market Price

Cold Water Bluepoint Oysters

  • 100 count

Market Price

Steamer Clams

  • 10-pound minimum. Littlenecks middlenecks and topnecks 100 count

Market Price

Live Maine (Hard Shell) Lobster

  • From 1-8 pounds

Market Price

Clam Chowder

$6.95 cup / $14.95 quart

Shrimp Corn Chowder

$6.95 cup / $14.95 quart

Lobster Bisque

$8.95 cup / $16.95 quart

Peanut Butter

$2 single / $9 half / $18 dozen

Chocolate Chip

$2 single / $9 half / $18 dozen

Lobster Roll

  • Sweet Maine lobster lightly toasted with mayo chopped celery and scallion served on a butter toasted bun. Also available Connecticut style in hot butter.

Market Price

Cuban Sandwich

  • Traditional Tampa style Cuban pressed

$15.95

The Mermaid

  • Featuring house-made tuna salad served on top of a lettuce leaf in a toasted ciabatta roll

$12.95

The Cortez

  • Ham and cheese with sweet apricot spread and mayo pressed in a toasted roll

$14.95

Cole Slaw

$2 single / $7.95 quart

Black Bean Salad

$2 single / $7.95 quart

Cape Cod Chips

$2 (single only)

Lobster, Cream Cheese & Scallion Quiche

$32.95

Quiche Lorraine Bacon, Ham & Swiss

$22.95

Apple Pie

$5.95 slice / $22.95 whole

View Full Menu PDF

Customer Reviews

Flat lay photo of Key Lime Pie

Our Hours


Call ahead to order
1.941.254.4783

Wed to Sat 11:00 – 4:00
Sun to Tues Closed